Do you think introducing blue cards for 10 minute sin-bins is a good idea for football? 🤔

:rotating_light:NEW RULE: Blue card in football.

It will be used to force a player off the field for 10 minutes if he commits a foul that prevents an attack deemed dangerous or if he protests a lot to a referee.

A blue card + a yellow card will result in a red card.

2 blue cards will result in red.

A first phase of testing will take place, possibly in the FA Cup. It will initially not be used in major competitions.

Is this a good idea for football? Share your thoughts on this new development in this thread!


What problem is it aimed at solving?
Any player that goes off the pitch for 10mins is of great advantage to his team.
He’ll read the game better, get some rest and also get details from the coach, come back with some fresh energy…:man_shrugging:t5:

This is unnecessary to me.


The potential benefits of introducing blue cards for 10-minute sin-bins in football include:

  • Effective Management of Player Behaviour: Blue cards can help manage dissent and tactical fouls more effectively, leading to a reduction in such offenses and a smoother running of the game.

  • Trialed Success in Amateur and Youth Football: Sin bins, indicated by blue cards, have been successful in amateur and youth football, with high approval rates from players, managers, and referees.

  • Support from the International Football Association Board (IFAB): The decision to introduce blue cards for sin bins is supported by the IFAB and is part of ongoing efforts to improve the sport’s rules and regulations.

The potential drawbacks of introducing blue cards for 10-minute sin-bins in football include:

  • Subjectivity: The use of blue cards could add an extra layer of subjectivity to the game, which could lead to confusion and inconsistency in decision-making.

  • Gimmick: The excitement of a team being down to ten men for ten minutes could be seen as a gimmick, rather than a genuine attempt to improve the game.

  • Not Addressing Long-Term Gripes: The proposals for blue cards and sin bins may not address long-term gripes with the game, such as the offside and handball laws, time-wasting, and ball-in-play statistics.

The trials are expected to provide valuable data on the impact of this system on the professional game, and the decision to introduce blue cards is supported by the IFAB. However, the effectiveness of this approach will be determined by the outcomes of the trials and the feedback from the football community.


I think it’s worth testing.

This new system will require real-time adjustments in the teams. When a player receives a blue card and is sent to the sin bin, the team will need to adjust tactically to compensate for being temporarily down to ten players. Coaches may need to make strategic substitutions to maintain the team’s competitive edge during the player’s absence. This could lead to a more dynamic approach to in-game management, with coaches having to carefully consider the timing and impact of their substitutions to mitigate the temporary numerical disadvantage.


The introduction of blue cards for 10-minute sin-bins in football is aimed at significantly improving player behaviour and, by extension, the overall quality of the game. The use of blue cards is a strategic response to the growing concerns over dissent and cynical fouls plaguing the sport.

The severity of the foul or breach of code determines the colour of the card. A player receives a yellow card for dissent, non-serious fouls, or breaking the flow of play. A blue card is given for more serious offenses, such as cynical tackles that are not in the range of red cards but are still serious. The use of blue cards is expected to help players avoid a three-match ban for a serious foul. However, being a more serious case than a yellow card, a player could still end up serving a ban after picking a blue card.

The blue card would be used to enforce sin bins during matches, and players could be forced to sit out 10 minutes of action for cynical fouls or displays of dissent. As a result, players may become more mindful of their conduct, knowing that they could face temporary expulsion from the game for certain infractions. This, in turn, could lead to improved player discipline and a more positive on-field atmosphere.

The phased approach to the introduction of blue cards allows for comprehensive assessment and fine-tuning of the rules before potential wider implementation. The true efficacy of the blue card system in influencing player behaviour will be closely monitored as the trials proceed.


:blue_square: BREAKING: Trials of the blue card in football has been delayed after the backlash spooked the lawmakers.

:newspaper_roll: @TeleFootball


:rotating_light: FIFA will insist that no trials of blue cards for dissent and cynical tactical fouls are undertaken at elite level, which could rule out the possibility of them being used in next season’s FA Cup.

(Source: @TimesSport)


:rotating_light: 𝗕𝗥𝗘𝗔𝗞𝗜𝗡𝗚: If a goalkeeper receives a blue card, it will force teams to choose between sticking an outfield player in goal or making a permanent substitution under these new sin-bin trials.

:newspaper_roll: @TeleFootball


Thank you for share with us.